EN 10028 and ASME SA-516: Two Standards Frameworks, One Shared Goal for Pressure Vessels

In pressure vessel manufacturing, the choice of steel plate cannot be based solely on mechanical strength or the availability of a particular thickness. The material must meet the equipment’s design, manufacturing and service conditions, as well as the code or standards framework required by the project.

In Europe, the main references are EN 10028-2 and EN 10028-3, commonly used within the framework of the Pressure Equipment Directive (PED) 2014/68/EU. For projects designed to American codes, one of the most widely used specifications is ASME SA-516, which shares the same technical basis as ASTM A516 for carbon steel plate intended for welded pressure vessels.

These are two different frameworks, each with its own requirements, grade designations and documentation. However, they pursue the same goal: to ensure that the material used in a pressure-retaining component is suitable for its application, has verifiable properties and remains traceable throughout the manufacturing process.

Why material standards are critical

A pressure vessel operates with stored energy. For this reason, design must take into account more than pressure alone: service temperature, the contained fluid, operating cycles, thickness, weldability, required toughness and the equipment’s risk category all play a role.

Among other aspects, the material standard defines the permitted chemical composition, the mechanical properties that must be met, the applicable tests, the delivery condition and the information that must appear in the mill documentation. This enables the manufacturer, quality personnel and, where applicable, the inspection body to verify that the plate installed is the same material specified and used in the project’s design calculations.

In these applications, the material and its certificate form an inseparable whole. A plate that cannot be identified by its heat number, or that lacks the required documentation, may be unsuitable for manufacturing even if its apparent properties are similar.

The European framework: EN 10028 and PED 2014/68/EU

Directive 2014/68/EU, known as the PED (Pressure Equipment Directive), establishes essential safety requirements for certain pressure equipment and assemblies placed on the European Union market. The Directive does not replace product standards; it defines the safety and conformity assessment framework within which materials are selected, justified and documented.

For steel plate intended for pressure vessels, the EN 10028 standards are a key reference. The most relevant parts of this family include:

  • EN 10028-2: flat products made of non-alloy and alloy steels with specified elevated-temperature properties.
  • EN 10028-3: flat products made of weldable fine-grain steels, supplied in the normalized or normalized-rolled condition.

Common grades include P265 GH and P355 GH under EN 10028-2, as well as P355 NH, P355 NL1 and P355 NL2 under EN 10028-3.

What distinguishes EN 10028 grades

Grade designations provide important information for material selection. In general terms, GH grades are used when a project requires specified properties for elevated-temperature service. This is why P265 GH and P355 GH are common choices for boilers, heat exchangers, process vessels and other equipment subjected to pressure and temperature.

NH and NL grades are intended for applications where toughness and performance at lower temperatures are particularly important. P355 NH is supplied in the normalized condition and is used when low-temperature toughness properties are required. The P355 NL1 and P355 NL2 grades extend this capability to more demanding low-temperature service conditions.

The choice between P265 GH, P355 GH, P355 NH and P355 NL should not be made on the basis of a general similarity in strength. It must be based on design calculations, minimum and maximum design temperatures, impact testing requirements, welding procedures and the code applicable to the equipment.

The American framework: ASME SA-516

For projects developed under the ASME Code, particularly in pressure vessel manufacturing, process industries, Oil & Gas and international export projects, ASME SA-516 is a commonly used specification for carbon steel plate.

SA-516 forms part of the ASME Code and is used primarily for plate intended for welded pressure vessels operating at moderate and low temperatures. Its technical basis is aligned with ASTM A516, while general delivery requirements may be supplemented by specifications such as SA-20/ASTM A20.

The most widely used grades are SA-516 Grade 60 and SA-516 Grade 70. Both are intended for boiler and pressure vessel fabrication, although they offer different levels of mechanical strength.

SA-516 Grade 60 and Grade 70

SA-516 Grade 60 has lower strength than Grade 70 and may be suitable when the design places particular emphasis on forming, weldability or thickness requirements. SA-516 Grade 70, meanwhile, is one of the most widely used grades for process vessels designed to the ASME Code, thanks to its combination of strength and fabrication performance.

Selection between the two grades must take into account design calculations, the specified thickness, welding procedures, impact testing requirements and operating temperature. A higher-strength grade is not necessarily the right choice for every item of equipment.

Two standards frameworks, several points in common

Although EN 10028 and ASME SA-516 belong to different technical frameworks, they share fundamental principles for ensuring the safety and reliability of pressure vessels:

  • Materials specified for pressure applications: these are not generic structural steels, but grades specified for pressure-containing equipment.
  • Verifiable mechanical properties: yield strength, tensile strength, elongation and, where applicable, toughness requirements assessed through Charpy impact testing.
  • Chemical composition control: essential to ensure material performance and suitability for welding and fabrication processes.
  • Heat traceability: material identification must be maintained from the steel mill through to equipment manufacturing.
  • Inspection documentation: test results and compliance with the specification must be supported by material certificates.
  • Verification against project requirements: the plate must fully comply with the specification required by the design calculations, design code and service conditions.

Main differences between EN 10028 and ASME SA-516

Aspect European framework American framework
Common reference EN 10028-2 and EN 10028-3 ASME SA-516
Application context Equipment designed to European standards and projects subject to the PED Equipment designed to the ASME Code, commonly used in international projects
Grade designations P265 GH, P355 GH, P355 NH, P355 NL1/NL2 SA-516 Grade 60 and Grade 70
Technical focus Distinguishes elevated-temperature performance from normalization and low-temperature requirements Carbon steel plate for welded pressure vessels operating at moderate and low temperatures
Typical documentation EN 10204 3.1 inspection certificate, according to project requirements MTR or CMTR, in accordance with ASME and purchase requirements
Interchangeability There is no automatic substitution between grades: any substitution must be validated by the responsible engineering team and under the applicable conformity framework.

Are P355 GH and SA-516 Grade 70 equivalent?

P355 GH and SA-516 Grade 70 may have comparable strength ranges under certain conditions, but they should not be considered directly equivalent or automatically interchangeable.

Each specification establishes its own requirements for manufacturing, chemical composition, testing, acceptance criteria, delivery conditions and documentation. Furthermore, choosing one or the other is linked to the equipment’s design code and the market where it will be placed into service.

For a vessel designed to European standards and subject to the PED, the use of an ASME material may require specific justification in the project’s technical documentation. Likewise, a project designed to the ASME Code must use materials accepted by that code and by the applicable purchasing specifications.

The decision must always rest with the engineering team responsible for the design. Comparing grades can help clarify their differences, but it does not replace the necessary technical and documentary validation.

Documentation: the link between steel plate and the finished vessel

Material documentation provides evidence that the plate received matches the specified grade and that its manufacturing and test results meet the applicable requirements. For European projects, the most common document for this purpose is an EN 10204 type 3.1 inspection certificate. For ASME projects, the information is generally recorded in a Mill Test Report or Certified Mill Test Report, in accordance with the specified supply requirements.

Depending on the scope of the project, the documentation should clearly identify:

  • The standard and grade of the material supplied.
  • The heat number or traceability reference.
  • The heat’s chemical composition.
  • The results of applicable mechanical tests.
  • The material’s delivery condition, where relevant.
  • The dimensions and thickness of the plates delivered.
  • Any additional requirements agreed upon in the purchase order, such as ultrasonic testing or third-party inspections.

Traceability must also be maintained during subsequent operations such as cutting, beveling, forming or part identification. If a plate is divided into smaller pieces, the documentary link between each resulting piece and the original heat must be preserved.

How to choose the right standard for a project

The starting question should not be which plate most closely resembles another, but rather which code and design conditions the equipment must meet. Before selecting the material, it is advisable to define:

  • The applicable design and manufacturing code.
  • The equipment’s destination country or market.
  • The design pressure and minimum and maximum design temperatures.
  • The process fluid and potential degradation mechanisms.
  • Impact testing, welding, heat treatment and inspection requirements.
  • The PED category, where the equipment will be placed on the European Union market.
  • The documentation required by the customer, engineering team or inspection body.

With this information, it is possible to determine whether the project requires an EN 10028 grade, an ASME SA-516 grade or another material specification better suited to the service conditions.

Mayor Steel: steel plate supply for PED and ASME projects

Mayor Steel supplies pressure vessel plate in accordance with the European standards EN 10028-2 and EN 10028-3, including grades such as P265 GH, P355 GH, P355 NH and P355 NL. The company also supplies ASME SA-516 Grade 60 and Grade 70 plate for projects designed to the ASME Code.

Materials are supplied with the complete documentation required for each grade and full plate traceability, an essential factor in the manufacture of boilers, process vessels, heat exchangers, autoclaves, reactors and other pressure equipment.

Working to the correct standard from the outset helps prevent unapproved substitutions, documentation issues and delays during inspection or commissioning. Because in pressure vessel manufacturing, meeting the specification is not simply about supplying steel: it means delivering material that is identified, verifiable and suitable for the project.

Scroll to Top